{"specification":"a2a2p","spec_version":"1.90.0-draft","spec_url":"https://a2a2p.com/spec","implementation":"a2a2p.com (reference implementation)","implementation_version":"1.423.265","declared_level":"L3 — Resolves","levels":{"L1_speaks":{"met":true,"evidence":"review_specification accepts intent.purpose alone and returns findings + quote_readiness. MCP + REST."},"L2_prices":{"met":true,"evidence":"get_supply_options returns pricing_kind=model_estimate with basis, confidence, and a not-a-quote disclaimer; §5.2.1 separately defines provider_estimate and provider_quote."},"L3_resolves":{"met":true,"evidence":"request_physical_solution returns synchronously with an embedded spec_review before async resolution; identifiers remain resolvable via check_request_status."},"L4_fabricates":{"met":false,"evidence":"Screening per §5.5 IS live with a published policy at /policy. Slant 3D V2 account, platform, exact-byte file upload, and one provider estimate are verified. A protected operator path can create one provider-side DRAFT after strict screening, principal verification, and a fresh runtime check of the pinned create/read/production-transition contract, but the client has no process-order, payment, or fabrication operation; public provider routing remains gated. No CNC or sheet-metal vendor exposes a self-serve buyer-side API to bridge to. The reference implementation does not broker fulfilment or accept production orders."}},"provider_status_reporting":{"section":"§5.7","met":true,"evidence":"GET /api/providers publishes a confirmed status, the raw most recent probe, and a measured 24-hour reliability window (samples, availability, probe latency, last failure). A transient probe failure is retried once inside the sample and reported as `degraded` until a second consecutive failure confirms it; `auth_error` and `configuration_error` publish immediately. Availability is a2a2p's own reachability measurement, explicitly not a provider service-level commitment and explicitly not fulfilment capability.","why":"On 2026-08-02 a single 15-second probe timeout published `down` for a provider API that answered five consecutive external requests in ~150 ms. One sample is not evidence."},"provider_call_boundary":{"active":true,"public_provider_routing":false,"policy":{"global_daily_estimates":200,"caller_hourly_estimates":5,"estimate_cache_ttl_hours":24,"idempotency":"Content-addressed on the exact inspected bytes plus the exact requested options. An identical repeat is served from the recorded provider result and spends no budget.","fails_closed":"If budget storage is unavailable, provider calls are refused rather than allowed.","scope":"Estimate-only. This boundary governs how often a2a2p may ask a provider for a price. It confers no order, payment, or fabrication capability."},"note":"The bounded budget and content-addressed idempotency that govern every call Invention Commons Protocol makes to a real provider account are live and exercised by the operator-only estimate probe. The DRAFT path has a separate runtime contract gate, published at /api/providers, that fails closed on stale, unavailable, corrupt, incomplete, or changed semantics. Measured provider latency is currently the binding constraint for public estimates, not availability: read reliability.latency_health at /api/providers. Public provider routing remains off; its activation conditions — measured reliability sufficient for a trend, a second additive estimate source, live-verified budget enforcement, and synchronized public copy — are published in docs/FULFILLMENT_ACTIVATION.md. Provider status being `up` is not one of them."},"fulfillment_containment":{"contract":"a2a2p.fulfillment-containment","version":"1.0.0","state":"dormant_legacy_handlers_fail_closed","route_gate":{"active":true,"behavior":"Every legacy fulfillment path returns fulfillment_not_active before legacy dispatch."},"handler_gate":{"active":true,"behavior":"Every retained legacy route handler independently returns before reading, writing, notifying, emailing, or calling a provider.","handler_count":18,"handlers":["handleSuppliers","handleSupplierPortal","handleSupplierEdit","handleApiSuppliers","handleApiSupplierProfile","handleApiSupplierRfq","handleCreateAuction","handleAuctionView","handleAuctionBid","handleAuctionAward","handleRating","handleRfq","handleProcurePage","handleProcureSubmit","handleAccept","handleVerifySupplier","handleOrderView","handleOrderStatusUpdate"]},"activation":{"status_flag_sufficient":false,"route_change_sufficient":false,"handler_change_required":true,"replacement_review_required":true,"live_verification_required":true},"authority":{"supplier_registration":false,"supplier_contact":false,"rfq_delivery":false,"bid_collection":false,"auction_award":false,"order_state_change":false,"payment":false,"fabrication":false}},"rate_limit":{"met":true,"contract":"a2a2p.rate-limit@2.0.0","schema":"https://a2a2p.com/schema/rate-limit","evidence":"Every public JSON 429 includes an RFC 9110 Retry-After delta, a stable scope, fixed-window recovery semantics, best-effort distributed-counter precision, and no raw client identity. Denied retries cannot move the boundary. Conformance probes treat an explicit 429 as not_evaluated rather than a semantic failure."},"known_gaps":["Provider reliability is measured only from a2a2p's own edge, on one adapter, at a 10-minute cadence. It is not a provider service-level commitment, it cannot distinguish a provider outage from a network path failure, and a single adapter means there is no redundancy to fail over to. A second additive or PCB estimate source is required before any provider is treated as infrastructure.","STEP solid volume now comes from the exporting CAD system's own geometric validation property where one is written: read from the file, unit-resolved from the shape's representation context, sanity-checked against the measured bounding box, and labeled `declared_validation_property` — never measured here and never composed across an assembly. Where no unambiguous property exists, volume stays unknown: the Invention Commons Protocol does not evaluate trimmed NURBS. Envelope, units, and feature-based machining complexity are read directly. STL meshes that Invention Commons Protocol has checked are closed solids are measured fully and keep the stronger `measured_mesh` provenance; one that is not closed, or was cut short, keeps its measured bounding box and reports no volume.","Estimates are parametric, not supplier-derived, wherever a provider adapter cannot serve the request. Calibrated 2026-08-02 against 25 price observations (24 published, 1 authenticated provider estimate) across 9 process tokens: 23/25 bands hit (92%), median 1.8x high, lead times 17/18. 24 published price benchmarks plus one authenticated Slant provider estimate. No binding provider quote, draft or accepted order, shipping price, charge, fabrication, or delivery outcome has been validated. Remaining limits: Without measured solid geometry, part volume is inferred from the bounding box and remains weak for tapered, hollow, or lattice parts; STEP currently supplies a measured envelope and complexity but not B-rep solid volume. The measured-geometry complexity multiplier has one controlled published A/B calibration pair, so it is deliberately bounded. The one live provider estimate covers a tiny quantity-one PLA FDM part only; it does not validate other geometry, quantities, materials, providers, shipping, or taxes. CNC quantity discount remains slightly too steep around 100 units. Method and evidence: https://a2a2p.com/evidence/calibration","Screening is deterministic pattern matching: it cannot read intent, so benign requests are occasionally flagged and paraphrase can evade it. Attached design files are additionally checked for actual format and bounded embedded metadata, but ordinary components cannot reliably reveal a future assembly. Cross-request assembly inference is an open manufacturing-safety problem; the Invention Commons Protocol will align with evidence-based industry practice as it emerges rather than claim to have solved it. Validated 2026-07-31 against a 45-request benign corpus spanning sensitive-adjacent domains (hunting, medical, automotive, locks, drones, rocketry, lab): zero legitimate requests denied, 11/11 safety-critical parts correctly flagged for human review before fabrication."],"conformance_kit":{"contract":"a2a2p.conformance-kit","version":"1.8.170","source":"https://a2a2p.com/conformance/a2a2p-conformance-kit-1.8.170.tgz","license":"CC0-1.0","outcome_semantics":{"vocabulary":["pass","fail","not_evaluated"],"rate_limited":"not_evaluated","not_evaluated_counts_as_pass":false,"not_evaluated_counts_as_failure":false,"not_evaluated_certifies_current_level":false,"selected_group_certifies_current_level":false,"mcp_selected_group_certifies_binding":false,"group_selection_flag":"--group=<name>","group_catalog_flag":"--list-groups","recovery_plan_contract":"a2a2p.conformance-recovery-plan@1.0.0","automatic_retry_authorized":false,"exit_codes":{"complete":0,"failed":1,"indeterminate":2}},"commands":{"semantic":"npm exec --yes --package=https://a2a2p.com/conformance/a2a2p-conformance-kit-1.8.170.tgz -- a2a2p-conformance https://a2a2p.com","mcp_2026":"npm exec --yes --package=https://a2a2p.com/conformance/a2a2p-conformance-kit-1.8.170.tgz -- a2a2p-mcp-conformance https://a2a2p.com"},"artifact":{"path":"/conformance/a2a2p-conformance-kit-1.8.170.tgz","url":"https://a2a2p.com/conformance/a2a2p-conformance-kit-1.8.170.tgz","integrity_path":"/conformance/a2a2p-conformance-kit-1.8.170.json","integrity_url":"https://a2a2p.com/conformance/a2a2p-conformance-kit-1.8.170.json","sha256":"a534489d758b7ed60714bdea2d761abef7596e83099811fc15c14cec14d5b6d7","bytes":123332}},"verify_yourself":"npm exec --yes --package=https://a2a2p.com/conformance/a2a2p-conformance-kit-1.8.170.tgz -- a2a2p-conformance https://a2a2p.com — fetched anonymously from this versioned public artifact, executable without cloning or repository access, and usable against any implementation, including competitors. It independently reports L3 here: L4 prerequisites are met, but a healthy provider does not become fabrication capability while public fulfillment is explicitly inactive.","note":"Conformance is self-declared; §7 establishes no certifying authority, deliberately. Corrections and competing implementations welcome: hello@a2a2p.com"}